How to Choose the Right EDI Approach for Your Business?

How to Choose the Right EDI Approach for Your Business?

Understand the differences between managed EDI, cloud platforms, and in-house integrations — and how to choose the option that supports your growth.

In This Session, You’ll Learn:

  • The 3 major EDI deployment models — Fully Managed, Hybrid, and In-House
  • When each model makes the most sense based on business size and complexity
  • How to evaluate your EDI needs across trading partners, document volumes, and
    IT resources
  • Common pitfalls companies face when selecting an EDI provider — and how to
    avoid them
  • How to plan for future scalability without overspending today.

Best For: CEOs, CTOs, VPs of IT, IT Directors, IT Managers, EDI Managers, Special
Projects Directors, Customer Success Directors, Project Managers

Related Topics: EDI implementation, onboarding, trading partner management,
cloud EDI

Key Takeaways

  • There’s no one-size-fits-all EDI approach — the right choice matches your
    workflow and growth plans
  • Control vs. convenience is the core decision: who manages maps, onboarding,
    and issues?
  • Good EDI decisions require clear scope and long-term visibility
  • Choosing based on sales pressure instead of business fit leads to costly rework

Session Overview

Choosing an EDI provider is one of the most impactful decisions a growing business makes — but most organizations aren’t sure how to evaluate their options. In this session, Jim Gonzalez breaks down the three major EDI approaches: fully managed, hybrid, and in-house. He explains how each model fits a different stage of growth, IT maturity, trading partner complexity, and operational workflow. Jim also shares practical tools — including an EDI Provider Evaluation Checklist, Scoring Sheet, and Scope of Work Template — that help teams define requirements clearly and compare solutions objectively. The core message is simple: your ideal EDI approach is the one that aligns with how your business operates today and where it’s headed over the next 3–5 years.

Go Deeper: Your Practical Blueprint for Planning and Implementing EDI the Right Way

Just getting started with EDI? This beginner’s guide explains the entire EDI landscape,
what to expect, how to prepare, and the essential steps to launch EDI successfully —
without the confusing jargon or IT frustration.

book

Full Transcript

00:00 – 01:00 | Introduction

Good morning, everyone. Jim Gonzalez here from EDI Support LLC. Today we’re answering a major question we hear often:

How do you choose the right EDI solution for your business?

Many companies talk to multiple providers—three or four conversations—yet still can’t decide. My goal today is to help you make that decision confidently by understanding the EDI landscape and matching the right approach to your business needs.

I’ll also share helpful evaluation tools you can request from our team.

01:00 – 02:30 | The Challenge Businesses Face

Even after vendor demos, pricing quotes, and feature overviews, teams often remain unsure:

  • Is this too complex?
  • Are we overpaying?
  • Will we outgrow this?
  • Do we need more control?

This session breaks down the three main EDI models so you can quickly determine which makes sense for your organization.

02:30 – 04:00 | Model #1 — Fully Managed EDI

Best for:
 Small businesses, startups, and lean teams with little to no IT or EDI resources.

How it works:

  • Provider manages onboarding, mapping, monitoring, support
  • Minimal integration needed
  • Very fast to implement

Trade-off:

  • Less visibility and customization
  • Often referred to as a “black box” approach

Ideal scenario:
 A small manufacturer with 2–3 trading partners exchanging <100 documents per month.

Elevate excels here because it includes both the platform and an outsourced EDI team.

04:00 – 06:30 | Model #2 — Hybrid EDI

Best for:
 Mid-sized companies that want more control while still getting expert support.

How it works:

  • You retain access to maps and trading partner setup
  • Provider/partner supports implementation and scaling
  • More flexibility + ability to take over internally later

Common hybrid platforms:

  • Boomi
  • MuleSoft
  • Celigo
  • Cleo
  • io
  • Jitterbit

This model supports growing complexity like:

  • 20+ partners
  • Multiple ERPs
  • Custom workflows

It balances control with convenience.

06:30 – 09:00 | Model #3 — In-House / Self-Managed EDI

Best for: Enterprises with large volumes and a dedicated IT/EDI team

How it works:

  • All infrastructure and mapping handled internally
  • High customization capability
  • Providers can still assist for expertise

Use cases:

  • Proprietary ERP or warehouse systems
  • Tens of thousands of documents per week
  • Full control and deep automation needed

Trade-off:

  • Highest long-term cost
  • Requires strong internal resources

09:00 – 11:00 | How to Select the Right Model

Ask yourself:

  • How many trading partners do we support today—and in the next 3–5 years?
  • What document volumes and types do we handle monthly?
  • Do we have internal EDI or integration expertise?
  • What level of control do we truly need?
  • Are we trying to get compliant quickly—or transform workflows?

“There is no best EDI approach. There is only the best fit for your workflow, resources, and growth stage.”

EDI capability improves competitiveness and compliance, even for small companies.

11:00 – 14:00 | Tools to Make Better Decisions

We offer three tools to help evaluate solutions objectively:

Provider Evaluation Checklist
 Questions covering onboarding, usability, platform modernity, support quality, pricing transparency

Vendor Scorecard
 A ranking system comparing:

  • Integration flexibility
  • SLAs and responsiveness
  • Pricing structure
  • Platform performance

Scope Document Template
 Captures:

  • Trading partners
  • Document/doc volume
  • Labeling and logistics needs
  • Integration details

➡️ If a provider does not request detailed scoping — red flag

14:00 – 17:00 | Common Mistakes

Avoid:

  • Choosing based on sales pressure rather than operational fit
  • Buying enterprise tools when you only need simple automation
  • Ignoring scalability and future document growth
  • Failing to map trading partner flows before implementation

“Don’t buy a jet when what you need is a reliable car with GPS.”

Documentation upfront = fewer delays and lower cost later.

17:00 – 19:30 | Recommendations by Business Stage

Business Type

Best-Fit Model

Small Business

Fully Managed

Mid-Market

Fully Managed or Hybrid

Enterprise

Hybrid or In-House

Elevate continues to evolve — optimized today for SMB efficiency, expanding for enterprise needs over the next few years.

Most EDI projects fail not because EDI doesn’t work — but because the wrong approach is chosen.

19:30 – 21:00 | Next Steps and Support

If you’re attending NRF 2026 from Jan 11-13, we’ll be at Booth #6263 in NYC — stop by to discuss your EDI needs directly.

Recommended Next Steps

1

Compare Providers with the EDI Scorecard

Rank onboarding, support quality, pricing transparency, and integrations side-by-side.

2

Complete Your EDI Project Scope Template

Define trading partners, volumes, and workflows to get accurate proposals and timelines.

3

Schedule an EDI Strategy Consultation

Chat 1:1 with our experts to review your needs and identify the best approach.

Related Masterclasses

Stop Rushing into EDI-Fix Your Workflow First

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Learn more ➜

How to Get EDI Right from Day 1: A Setup Guide for Growing Businesses

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Learn more ➜

The EDI Pricing Trap: What SMBs Need to Know Before Signing

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.

Learn more ➜